Sandwiches in Amityville

Seafood sandwiches with crispy and steamed options await at Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food in Amityville, NY for pickup.

Order online

Sandwiches to Try

Flounder

Flounder is available as a sandwich or entrée, with optional styles.

Flounder Sandwich$15.99Flounder is served as a sandwich, with its preparation and seasoning left unspecified.
Old Bay Flounder Sandwich$15.99Flounder is served as a sandwich with Old Bay seasoning for a savory, spiced flavor.
Sazon Flounder Sandwich$15.99Flounder is served as a sandwich with Sazon seasoning, adding a seasoned flavor to the fish.
Flounder Entree$15.99Flounder is served as an entree, with its preparation and seasoning left unspecified.

“Me and my mom stopped in for once and all I can say is we’ll be back guaranteed. Staff was attentive and kind. We didn’t even wait till we got home to eat, the food was excellent. I got flounder with yams and mac and cheese and my mom got Tilapia with yellow rice.”

Shrimp & Scallops

Shrimp and scallops ordered as a sandwich or entree.

“So far we've had the fish, shrimp, scallops, Mac n cheese, yams, lima beans and the collard greens. Everything was exceptional. We will be returning ASAP to try everything else. In addition, their lemonades and customer service were also exceptional!!!”

Cat Fish

Catfish ordered as a sandwich or entree, with optional preparation choices.

Cod Fish

Cod fish sandwich with optional fried or steamed preparation styles.

Red Snapper

Red snapper is fish with optional fried or steamed preparation.

Tilapia Fish

$15.99

Tilapia fish with optional fried styles or steamed preparation.

“If you are going for a meat alternative during Lent, might I suggest Brooklyn Fish in the Amityville area? Tried the fried tilapia filets, and lemme tell ya, good eats. Wish I got the lady's name who served me up the fish and 2 dollops of tartar sauce, but she can carry a convo like water in a bucket. If yoU are in the area, try it out.”

Brooklyn Fish Sub

$8.99

Fish served in a sub sandwich, with the variety and toppings unspecified.

Brooklyn Fish Sub Combo

$10.99

This combo is a fish sandwich served on sub-style bread.

Codfish Sandwich Thursday

$12.99

A codfish sandwich marked as a Thursday special, with sides customizable.

Fish Cakes

$11.99

Fish formed into cakes, with optional steaming, frying, or seasonings.

Whiting

$12.99

Whiting fish with optional fried styles or steamed preparation.

Find Something Special at Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food

At Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food, sandwiches feature fish and shellfish, with sub and fish cake formats among the choices. Seasoning options include pepper and Sazon on select sandwiches.

Cod Fish comes with a steamed option, while Tilapia Fish can be fried crispy. Whiting offers Old Bay seasoning, and Cat Fish is available as a sandwich or an entree with a fried soft option.

Visit us in Amityville, NY for dine-in, pickup, or delivery. Pair BROOKLYN FISH SUB COMBO with French fries or macaroni salad; yellow rice and grits are also available as side options.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Whiting — Whiting is offered as fish, with fried styles or steaming available as customizations rather than a set preparation.
Flounder — Flounder can be ordered as a sandwich or entrée; steaming and several fried finishes are optional preparation choices.
Fish Cakes — These fish cakes are formed fish patties; optional preparation choices include steaming, frying, and different seasonings.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the Amityville area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.

Is there a kids menu?

Brooklyn Fish - Chicken & Soul Food offers kid-friendly options, including Fish & Fries Kids Meal and Chicken Finger & Fries Kids Meal.

Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.